These three self-hosted CMS platforms appeal to different kinds of teams rather than competing head to head on the same axis. CMS Made Simple is the choice…
Freemium (open source core + paid Pro/Assembly/Enterprise tiers) · From Free (Community Edition); Pro from $199/month
Best for: Agencies and software teams on a Node.js stack who want in-context live editing plus the option to run headless, with a formal paid ladder (Pro, Assembly, Enterprise) for growing needs.
Free/Open Source · From Free
Best for: Freelance designers and developers who want a lightweight, free PHP CMS with the Smarty template engine keeping design work fully separate from PHP logic on standard shared hosting.
Open Source · From Free
Best for: Enterprises, government agencies, and universities needing custom content types, multi-site governance, and enterprise-grade security at scale.
| Apostrophe | CMS Made Simple | Drupal | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary category | CMS | CMS | CMS |
| Rating | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented |
| Pricing model | Freemium (open source core + paid Pro/Assembly/Enterprise tiers) | Free/Open Source | Open Source |
| Starting price | Free (Community Edition); Pro from $199/month | Free | Free |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented |
| Platforms | Web | Web | Web |
| Team collaboration | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented |
| AI features | Yes | Not documented | Yes |
| Public API | Yes | Not documented | Yes |
Three different templating philosophies
CMS Made Simple is built around the Smarty template engine's strict separation of content, business logic, and templates, Drupal offers flexible custom content-type theming, and Apostrophe centers its architecture on a Node.js module system with in-context editing.
Apostrophe, CMS Made Simple, Drupal
Drupal dominates on ecosystem size
Drupal's community of more than 10,000 active contributors and its large contributed module library dwarf the smaller communities around Apostrophe and CMS Made Simple, both of which list a smaller ecosystem as a known tradeoff.
Apostrophe, CMS Made Simple, Drupal
Only Apostrophe offers true in-context editing
Apostrophe lets content editors work directly on the live rendered page. CMS Made Simple instead offers a real-time Content Manager with a WYSIWYG editor in a separate admin area, and Drupal's editorial experience improvements are bundled into its newer Drupal CMS starter package rather than in-context editing on the page itself.
Apostrophe
Hosting simplicity favors CMS Made Simple
CMS Made Simple needs only a standard LAMP or LEMP stack and has a lighter resource footprint than Drupal, while Apostrophe needs Node.js-compatible hosting (or its own managed hosting) and Drupal's total cost of ownership can climb once specialized hosting and development are factored in.
CMS Made Simple, Drupal, Apostrophe
Only Apostrophe has a formal commercial product ladder
Apostrophe is the only one of the three with named paid tiers (Pro, Assembly, Enterprise) and vendor-run managed hosting; CMS Made Simple and Drupal core are both entirely free, community-maintained open source projects with no official paid tier from the project itself.
Apostrophe, CMS Made Simple, Drupal
| Feature | Apostrophe | CMS Made Simple | Drupal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dedicated templating layer separating logic from design | Not documented | Available | Not documented |
| Headless/API-first content delivery | Available | Not documented | Available |
| Custom content types and fields | Not documented | Not documented | Available |
| Feature | Apostrophe | CMS Made Simple | Drupal |
|---|---|---|---|
| In-context/live visual editing on the page itself | Available | Not documented | Not documented |
| Feature | Apostrophe | CMS Made Simple | Drupal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Large contributed module/plugin ecosystem | Limited | Limited | Available |
| Official vendor-run managed hosting | Available | Unavailable | Unavailable |
| Formal paid/commercial tier with vendor support | Available | Unavailable | Unavailable |
Starting price reflects the lowest paid tier, not the full cost for every team size or usage level.
Pros
Cons
Pros
Cons
Pros
Cons
CMS Made Simple is a PHP CMS built around the Smarty template engine, which strictly separates templates from business logic. Apostrophe is a Node.js CMS built for in-context editing and optional headless delivery. Drupal is a PHP CMS focused on highly flexible, custom content modeling for complex sites.
CMS Made Simple, since it only needs a standard LAMP or LEMP stack (Linux, Apache or Nginx, MySQL, PHP) and has a lighter resource footprint than Drupal. Apostrophe needs Node.js-compatible hosting, and Drupal's total cost of ownership can climb once specialized hosting and development are factored in.
Apostrophe is the only one of the three that offers in-context visual editing, where editors work directly on the rendered page rather than a separate admin form. CMS Made Simple offers a real-time Content Manager with a WYSIWYG editor instead, and Drupal's editorial improvements ship through its newer Drupal CMS starter bundle.
Only Apostrophe has a formal commercial ladder, with Pro, Assembly, and Enterprise tiers plus its own managed hosting. CMS Made Simple and Drupal core are both free, community-maintained open source projects without an official paid tier from the project itself, though third-party Drupal hosts like Acquia and Pantheon sell commercial plans.
Drupal, by a significant margin, with more than 10,000 active contributors and a large contributed module library. Both Apostrophe and CMS Made Simple explicitly list a smaller plugin and theme ecosystem as a tradeoff in their own pros and cons.
Drupal is the strongest fit for large, complex organizations that need custom content modeling, multi-site management, and enterprise security. CMS Made Simple suits freelance designers and small agencies wanting a lightweight PHP CMS, while Apostrophe fits agencies on a Node.js stack that want in-context editing with room to grow into paid tiers.
Read the full Apostrophe review · Read the full CMS Made Simple review · Read the full Drupal review